RecruitLocalPros

Reference Check Questions That Tell You Something

Reference checks fail when the questions invite a yes. These are tied to the duties of the seat.

Built on the duties O*NET documents for the occupation. Free, nothing gated, every figure named for what it is.

  • 23 to 35 daysto fill a roletypical, not a promise
  • 86%fill rateon active searches
  • 30 to 50%lower than contingency2 to 3x faster

A reference verifies. It does not evaluate.

The useful reference call has one job: find out whether the account you were given in the interview matches what the person who was there remembers. That is why "would you hire them again" is a weak opener. It asks for a verdict, and a verdict is the one thing a former manager has every reason to soften.

Ask instead about things with a right answer. Dates. Title. What they owned. How big it was. Who it reported to. Specific answers that match are the signal. Hesitation on a factual question is a louder signal than a tepid opinion.

Seven questions, in order

  1. What were the dates, and what was the title at the end? Start with the two things most often stretched.
  2. What did they own, as opposed to contribute to? The gap between those two is where most resume inflation lives.
  3. How big was it? Headcount, budget, accounts, volume, whatever the work is measured in. A number should come back without effort.
  4. Who did they work with most, and what did those people rely on them for? This produces the most honest answer on the call, because it is not about rating them.
  5. What would they have needed help with in the first ninety days? Not a weakness question. A ramp question, and it is the one you will use.
  6. Why did they leave? Then compare it with what the candidate said. You are not looking for a bad reason, only for two accounts that do not meet.
  7. Is there anything you would want to know if you were me? Ask it last, then stop talking. The pause does the work.

What to verify against, by occupation

Question two and three only work if you know what the job involves. The duties O*NET documents for the occupation give you the checklist: ask which of these the candidate personally did, rather than asking in general terms whether they were good at the job.

Computer and Information Research Scientists

Ask which of these they owned, and what the volume was:

  • Analyze problems to develop solutions involving computer hardware and software.
  • Apply theoretical expertise and innovation to create or apply new technology, such as adapting principles for applying computers to new uses.
  • Assign or schedule tasks to meet work priorities and goals.
  • Meet with managers, vendors, and others to solicit cooperation and resolve problems.

Computer and Information Systems Managers

Ask which of these they owned, and what the volume was:

  • Direct daily operations of department, analyzing workflow, establishing priorities, developing standards and setting deadlines.
  • Meet with department heads, managers, supervisors, vendors, and others, to solicit cooperation and resolve problems.
  • Review project plans to plan and coordinate project activity.
  • Assign and review the work of systems analysts, programmers, and other computer-related workers.

Duties from O*NET, the US Department of Labor occupational database. Every occupation on this site carries its own list.

Two things that void the whole exercise

  • Running it after the offer. At that point nobody acts on what they hear, so the call is a formality. Between final interview and offer is the only window where the answer can change a decision.
  • Letting the candidate pick the only manager you speak to. Ask for a specific former manager by name and role, from the job that matters most. A reference list assembled for you is a reference list selected for you.

A call you place yourself is not a screening report. One you pay a company to place is. What a background check costs and what it is allowed to cover is a separate question with its own rules.

Questions about reference check questions

What is a reference check actually for?
Verification, not evaluation. The candidate has already told you what they did. The reference tells you whether that account matches what the person who was there remembers. Treating the call as a second opinion on whether to hire is how it gets skipped as useless.
What if the company will only confirm dates and title?
Many will, as policy, and that is still worth the call because dates and title are what gets inflated most often. For anything beyond that, ask the candidate for a former manager or peer directly rather than going through the main line.
How many references are enough?
Two who actually worked with them beats four who were collected to fill a form. One should be someone who managed them, because a peer cannot speak to how they took direction.
Can references be checked before an offer?
Yes, and that is the point of doing them: a reference call after the offer is out changes nothing, because almost nobody withdraws an offer over a lukewarm reference. Run them between the final interview and the offer.
Is a reference check the same as a background check?
Not usually, and the difference is who places the call. A reference call you make yourself is not a consumer report and carries none of the federal screening steps. Pay a screening company to make it and the result is a consumer report, and because it is built from personal interviews about character and reputation it is an investigative consumer report, which adds disclosure duties of its own on top of the ordinary ones. So the rules follow who called, not what was discussed.

Other resources for the same hire

Salary Benchmarking

Set a band from the published market rate where you are hiring, not from a national average.

Job Description Template

A template is easy. Knowing which duties belong in it and what the role pays is the part most of them leave out.

Interview Questions to Ask Candidates

Questions drawn from what the job actually involves, not a generic list.

What a Background Check Costs

Screening is a real line in the cost of a hire. Here is what it runs and what moves it.

Offer Letter Template

The pay clause is the only part of the letter that changes by role, so it carries the published band for the role.

Exit Interview Questions

An exit interview tells you about one person. The quit rate tells you whether it is one person or a pattern.

Recruiting Metrics

Every metric here is set against the national figure, so a number means something.

Why this is free

Setting the band and writing the brief is the half of hiring nobody helps with, and it decides whether the search works. RecruitLocalPros is a recruiting partner for employers: the requisition goes to a vetted recruiting partner who runs the search end to end, at a fee set by the seniority of the seat rather than a percentage of salary, which runs 30 to 50% lower than contingency against a contingency firm billing 20 to 30%, typically filling in 23 to 35 days. Typical figures, not promises.

See your price before you talk to anyone.

Answer a few questions about the role and you get your own number on screen. No call required, no commitment, and nothing to unsubscribe from.

23 to 35 days to fill. 86% fill rate on active searches.

Connect with us

Follow RecruitLocalPros