RecruitLocalPros

Interview Questions to Ask Candidates, Built From the Real Duties

Questions drawn from what the job actually involves, not a generic list.

Built on the duties and software O*NET documents for the occupation. Free, nothing gated, every figure named for what it is.

  • 23 to 35 daysto fill a roletypical, not a promise
  • 86%fill rateon active searches
  • 30 to 50%lower than contingency2 to 3x faster

Turning a duty into a question

Every occupation on this site carries the duties O*NET documents for it. A duty becomes a question in one move: ask for the last time they did that specific thing, then ask what went wrong.

  • Open on the duty. "Walk me through the last time you did X." Past tense, specific instance. A hypothetical invites a rehearsed answer.
  • Follow with the failure. "What went wrong, and what did you do?" This is the question that separates two candidates who both say yes to the first one.
  • Then the numbers. How often, how many, how long. Someone who has done the work has the scale at hand. Someone who has watched it does not.

Worked examples, from documented duties

Three occupations below. Each duty is the published one, and the question under it is the duty turned around. Every occupation on this site has its own duty list to do this with.

Architectural and Engineering Managers

  • Duty. Manage the coordination and overall integration of technical activities in architecture or engineering projects.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Direct, review, or approve project design changes.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Consult or negotiate with clients to prepare project specifications.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?

Tool question. This occupation is documented as working in Autodesk AutoCAD, Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Office software, Microsoft PowerPoint. Ask which of those they have used, then ask what they could not get it to do.

Bill and Account Collectors

  • Duty. Record information about financial status of customers and status of collection efforts.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Locate and notify customers of delinquent accounts by mail, telephone, or personal visits to solicit payment.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Locate and monitor overdue accounts, using computers and a variety of automated systems.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?

Tool question. This occupation is documented as working in Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Office software, Microsoft Outlook, Microsoft Word. Ask which of those they have used, then ask what they could not get it to do.

Billing and Posting Clerks

  • Duty. Verify accuracy of billing data and revise any errors.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Resolve discrepancies in accounting records.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?
  • Duty. Prepare itemized statements, bills, or invoices and record amounts due for items purchased or services rendered.
    Ask. Walk me through the last time you did that. What was the hardest version of it you have handled, and what did you change afterwards?

Tool question. This occupation is documented as working in Accounting software, Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Office software, Microsoft Outlook. Ask which of those they have used, then ask what they could not get it to do.

Duties and software from O*NET, the US Department of Labor occupational database.

Write the answer down before the interview

For each question, write one line on what a strong answer contains. Do it before anyone is in the room, because afterwards the answer you heard becomes the standard you were looking for. This single step is what makes a second interviewer's score comparable to the first one's.

The duties you built these questions from are the same ones that should be in the posting. The description structure is here, and what to ask the references afterwards is here.

Questions about interview questions to ask candidates

How many questions does an interview need?
Five or six asked properly, with follow-ups, tells you more than twenty asked once. The follow-up is where the answer stops being rehearsed, so plan for time rather than volume.
What makes a question worth asking?
It is about a duty the job actually has, and a person who has not done the work cannot answer it convincingly. "Tell me about yourself" fails both tests. "Walk me through the last time you closed a month with a variance you could not explain" fails neither.
Are behavioral or technical questions better?
They answer different things. A technical question tells you whether someone can do the task. A behavioral one tells you what they do when the task goes wrong, which is the part that varies between two people with the same resume. Most interviews are short on the second.
What should not be asked?
Three different tiers, and they get flattened into one list constantly. Federal law flatly bars disability and medical inquiries before an offer. Questions touching race, color, religion, sex including pregnancy, sexual orientation and gender identity, national origin, age from 40, and genetic information are not themselves prohibited by Title VII, but the EEOC treats them as evidence of discriminatory intent unless there is a business reason, which in an interview there almost never is. Marital status, family status and salary history are protected by some states and not by federal law. The practical rule covers all three: none of it predicts performance, so the question costs you something and buys nothing.
Is asking about marital status or children illegal?
Not under federal law as its own category. The EEOC treats those questions as potential evidence of sex discrimination under Title VII, and says asking them of women but not men is clearly discriminatory. Several states do protect marital or family status directly. Either way the question has no job-related use before an offer, so there is no version of it worth asking.
How do I keep two interviewers consistent?
Same questions, in the same order, with the answer you are listening for written down in advance. Without that, two interviewers are running two different interviews and the comparison at the end is not a comparison.

Other resources for the same hire

Salary Benchmarking

Set a band from the published market rate where you are hiring, not from a national average.

Job Description Template

A template is easy. Knowing which duties belong in it and what the role pays is the part most of them leave out.

Reference Check Questions That Tell You Something

Reference checks fail when the questions invite a yes. These are tied to the duties of the seat.

What a Background Check Costs

Screening is a real line in the cost of a hire. Here is what it runs and what moves it.

Offer Letter Template

The pay clause is the only part of the letter that changes by role, so it carries the published band for the role.

Exit Interview Questions

An exit interview tells you about one person. The quit rate tells you whether it is one person or a pattern.

Recruiting Metrics

Every metric here is set against the national figure, so a number means something.

Why this is free

Setting the band and writing the brief is the half of hiring nobody helps with, and it decides whether the search works. RecruitLocalPros is a recruiting partner for employers: the requisition goes to a vetted recruiting partner who runs the search end to end, at a fee set by the seniority of the seat rather than a percentage of salary, which runs 30 to 50% lower than contingency against a contingency firm billing 20 to 30%, typically filling in 23 to 35 days. Typical figures, not promises.

See your price before you talk to anyone.

Answer a few questions about the role and you get your own number on screen. No call required, no commitment, and nothing to unsubscribe from.

23 to 35 days to fill. 86% fill rate on active searches.

Connect with us

Follow RecruitLocalPros